Why Many People Avoid Retiring in New Jersey: Taxes, Costs, and Lifestyle Factors

Discover why many retirees avoid New Jersey. Explore taxes, cost of living, commute issues, and better retirement alternatives for a comfortable lifestyle.

I can barely wrap my head around why anyone would retire anywhere near New Jersey. For many retirees, that gut reaction stems from a few consistent concerns: high property taxes, relatively high cost of living, and the persistent noise and congestion near major urban centers. While New Jersey offers proximity to New York City and excellent healthcare options, those benefits don’t always outweigh the everyday costs and lifestyle trade-offs for people on fixed incomes.

Property taxes in New Jersey are among the highest in the nation, and that alone can derail retirement budgets. Even if you own your home outright, ongoing local taxes, higher utility bills, and expensive services add up. State taxes and sales taxes can also reduce the purchasing power of retirement savings, making retirement in New Jersey less attractive compared with states that offer tax advantages for retirees.

Beyond money, the pace and layout of many New Jersey suburbs aren’t ideal for everyone. Commuter traffic, crowded public spaces, and limited senior-friendly housing options can make day-to-day life stressful. Retirees often prioritize quiet neighborhoods, walkability, and access to nature—qualities more commonly found in other regions.

That said, New Jersey does have strengths worth considering. Its healthcare infrastructure is strong, with top hospitals and specialists nearby. Cultural amenities, restaurants, and short travel distances to major cities can be appealing for active retirees who value convenience and urban access.

If you’re weighing retirement choices, consider alternatives that frequently top “best places to retire” lists: neighboring Pennsylvania and Delaware offer lower taxes and quieter towns; Florida and Arizona provide warm climates and retiree-friendly tax rules; and parts of North Carolina and South Carolina combine affordable living with good healthcare. Each option has trade-offs, so evaluate what matters most to you.

Practical steps include running a detailed budget comparison, checking local property and state tax rules, assessing healthcare access, and visiting potential retirement communities in different seasons. Talk to a financial planner who understands retirement tax strategies and housing options. Ultimately, deciding where to retire is personal: New Jersey may suit some, but for many retirees looking to stretch savings and enjoy a slower pace, other states are often a better fit.

Back